We live in the age of information.
Theories, hypothesis, discussions, opinions, logic, and reason, these
things are the ruling factors of our education. In this well ordered
colaberation of thought, there seems to be little room (or importance
for that matter) of what we feel.
In her article “Big Time Sensuality” Jenny Edbaur begs to differ.
She argues that our “affect”, or what we feel when reading,
watching, or even writing something can be just as importance as the
ideology of the thing. She
doesn't discount the importance of the ideology, or the “meaning”
of what we read or see, but she states that the emotional connection
(the affect) that people have with something gives it a meaning that
cannot be expressed solely by the ideology. As an example she uses
rock music. She relates the account of professor by the name of
Grossberg, who tried to show the ideological meaning of rock music to
his students. The students, however, were unimpressed, as Edbaur
states, “the music mattered to students in spite of (or beyond) any
ideological meaning either given to them or from them.”
We
don't appreciate the importance of affect. We are embarrassed of
pleasure, of sensations. Often when we read or watch something
solely because of the way it makes us feel we call it a “guilty
pleasure”. If it's not intellectual or productive it is inherently
“bad”. But that is what we crave, and why not? We are meant to
experience this life, not just think our way through it; and just as we can't go through life based on
passions and emotions alone, we cannot go through life being only a
logical being. Some things can only be understood through the way it
affects us, and in fact, almost all of the most memorable experiences
of our lives are remembered, not because of what we thought during
the experience, but of how we felt during the experience, the
sensations we had. The most powerful movies or books we read are
powerful for the same reasons. This can be seen as well in Edbaur's
article. She described a student she had named Paul, who wrote
papers and blog posts in a very sensual way, (not sexual, sensual,
they are different things even if we don't always think of them as
different). He put feeling into his writing and it made all the
difference. Everyone loved what he wrote and wanted to write more
like him.
As
Edbaur stated, if we really want our compositions an writing to make
an impact, we get away from the “tyranny of ideological meaning
alone” and focus
more on how we feel.
i Love when you say "We are meant to experience this life, not just think our way through it," and i totally agree.
ReplyDeleteThis is a lovely post, Jared. Well done ;)
Jared, I love this line: "If it's not intellectual or productive it is inherently “bad”." I think you hit the proverbial nail on the head with this. All too often people seem to forget that while not socially acceptable, most aspects of humanity are necessary.
ReplyDelete